The Legend of Mothman | Ep. 14 In 1966, the West Virginia town of Point Pleasant had multiple witnesses and encounters with this creature that had wings and red eyes. This was the beginning of Mothman, which became a local urban legend. Its appearances ultimately foreshadowed the collapse of the Silver Bridge in the Ohio […]
The Cursed Cabin | Listener Submission | Ep. 13 It’s Friday and you’re listening to another Believing the Bizarre episode. This can only mean one thing… another listener submission episode! Coming to us all the way from Chile, this story, by listener Pask, involves playing with a ouija board and cursing a family cabin. Creepy […]
La Pascualita and The Expressionless | Ep. 12 A little unique opening to this Believing the Bizarre episode! Tyler wanted to make the creepypasta, The Expressionless, into an episode but wasn’t able to find an angle to make it work. Because, you know, it’s fake. So we read that story in full before diving into […]
Randonautica and the Mind | Ep. 11 Have you ever tried the Randonautica app? If you’ve gone randonauting, chances are you ended up visiting somewhere you otherwise would not have. Do you attribute this to your own free will, or is there something bigger at play? Charlie walks us through the gnosis element of Chaos […]
The Secrets of Antarctica | Ep. 10 This week on Believing the Bizarre, we tackle the major topic that is Antarctica. Not major just because Antarctica is big itself, but there are so many theories around this place! Hollow Earth, Nazi bases, UFOs, and more! Dive with us into the unknown and the unusual as […]
Paper Magic and the Girl | Listener Submission | EP. 9 Surprise! It’s another bonus episode thanks to fantastic listeners submitting their creepy stories! Today, we have a double-header. Our first story comes from Pennsylvania and involves abandoned buildings, satanic markings, and possible attachments. Our second tale takes place in Florida and involves an eerie […]
The Nameless Horror of 50 Berkeley Square | Ep. 8 *Disclaimer: due to a COVID-19 scare, this episode was recorded social distantly. The audio is a little subpar compared to what you’re used to, but the good news is, we are both fine.* But, you probably care more about the audio than our health. That’s […]
The Witching Hour | Ep. 7 What is The Witching Hour? Why do so many people seem to wake up around 3 AM? We dive into theories surrounding The Witching Hour aka The Devil’s Hour, along with a few urban legends and prominent stories. We asked a question on Twitter if anyone had questions regarding […]
The Great Dismal Swamp Mystery | Listener Submission | Ep. 6 We are excited to present our first listener submission story! Consider these stories little bonus episodes that exist outside of our normal Tuesday catalog. Our first story, submitted by William, brings us to Suffolk, Virginia, and the Great Dismal Swamp National Wildlife Refuge. From […]
The 27 Club | Ep. 5 Are you familiar with the 27 Club? It is an exclusive, yet tragic, group of ultra-talented artists that met their demise a little too soon. The obvious culprit appears to be suicide and drugs, however, is there a darker conspiracy at play? This week, we look at a few […]