Pennsylvania Cryptids This episode is all about Pennsylvania cryptids – that includes the noble squonk, a hideous and tragically ugly creature, the Giwoogle, a specific witch’s familiar, and the Waterford Sheepman, a tall and terrifying creature with the face of a sheep. Listen now. Pennsylvania Cryptids And Creatures: The Sheepman, Giwoogle, and the Squonk Have […]
The Bogg Creek Monster: Arkansas’ Bigfoot Imagine a tall, hairy creature staring at you from the shadows around Fouke, Arkansas. This week, we discuss the bigfoot-like entity, the Boggy Creek Monster. For over a century, the Boggy Creek Beast has terrified residents, stalked folks, killed cattle and dogs, and more. It is known to be […]
The Rougarou The Rougarou is a common legend among French Louisiana. This terrifying cryptid is known as Louisiana’s werewolf – it has sharp teeth, a furry body, and transforms from being a human. But, is this beast believable? Listen now to find out. What would you do if were bitten by a monster? Does the […]
The Celtic Selkie Have you witnessed a seal turn into a human? In this episode, we discuss the Norse and Celtic mythology of the Selkie, a creature that is known to exist as a seal in the water, shed its skin, and become a human on land. But, how believable is the selkie? Listen now! […]
Creature Feature Volume 2 If you enjoy personal encounters with cryptids, creatures, and blood-curling screams echoing throughout the night, this is the episode for you! This episode has 5 creepy encounters with creatures that are not easily defined (and often take place in Arizona). We loved doing Creature Feature Volume 1 and after the response […]
The Legend of the Wendigo Cryptid The Wendigo is a cryptid shrouded in mystery and fear. It has been described as a creature of pure evil, an ancient spirit with an insatiable hunger for human flesh. It has been talked about for centuries as a fearsome entity that lurks in the forests of North America, […]
The Melon Heads of Kirtland Legend says the Melon Heads wander the woods of Kirtland, have abnormally large heads, and are known to prey on small animals and cannibalize humans. Some say they were test subjects from the government and given to an old couple in the middle of the woods to take care of. […]
The Wampus Cat | Ep. 128 The Wampus Cat is a large, cat-like entity that is connected to Native American folklore. Also known as the Cherokee Death Cat, this beast is known for its six legs and terrifying cry. But, is it real? Listen now! What screams at night in the heart of the Appalachian […]
The Beast of Bray Road | Ep. 127 What is lurking in rural Wisconsin? Could there be a real werewolf that stalks around Bray Road? The beast of Bray Rd is known as a dog man that stands between 6 and 7 feet tall with grey and brown hair, a muscular build, and a dog […]
Creature Feature: Vol. 1 | Ep. 126 If you love real stories about creepy creatures that lurk in the woods and peer through your window late at night, this is a Believing the Bizarre episode you’re going to want to dive into. We have four listener submission stories that all revolve around bumping into cryptids […]