Haunted Lizzie Borden House This week, we dive into the infamous Lizzie Borden case and the alleged hauntings that followed. We explore the brutal 1892 murders of Andrew and Abby Borden in Fall River, Massachusetts, examining the tensions within the household—from Lizzie’s resentment toward her stepmother to Andrew’s frugal lifestyle despite his wealth. We discuss […]
The Deceitful Curandera This week, we explore three chilling listener submissions. First, Ashley shares her experience with a shadow figure that appeared in her college basement in Michigan, standing motionlessly before disappearing into a wall. Then Will tells us about multiple encounters at rental cabins in Helen, Georgia, including a terrifying face-off with a yellow-eyed […]
The Smiling Shadow This week, we dive into three chilling listener-submitted ghost stories. First, we explore an anonymous account from a Nigerian boarding school where students experienced mysterious disturbances – from violently shaking beds to objects moving on their own – that multiple witnesses confirmed. Next, we discuss Thomas’s experiences in his inherited trailer home, […]
Dreams of Destiny We have four strange and unusual listener submitted stories for you this week! 1 – Nicole’s Story: Greg, who died in a motorcycle accident, appeared to check on his baby son after death, and years later the child inexplicably described the exact way his father had died. Nicole also experienced a vivid […]
Hat Man Stories: Volume 1 It’s listener submission time and we have a handful of encounters with the legendary and spooky Hat man. As a reminder, the Hat Man is a tall, looming shadow figure that lurks around and is often seen with a wide brim hat and a cloak. He is often associated with […]
The Demonic Shadow in the Mirror It is listener submission time again! The first story follows Emma and her family in Colorado, where unexplained phenomena escalate from mysteriously stacked pots and pans to a child being repeatedly thrown from his bed, leading her coal miner father to make a difficult decision. Strange shadows with skeletal […]
The Lingering Shadow isaac Sasha’s story began when she moved into a house with her father and brother, instantly sensing an overwhelming, oppressive energy. Over time, a shadowy figure emerged—a towering presence she called Isaac. Its intentions were a mystery, but it seemed to grow more intrusive, hovering near her and leaving her with scratches […]
The Possession Survivor This week on Believing the Bizarre we have 3 creepy listener submitted stories. First, Jared and his sister experienced recurring supernatural events in their Indiana home. Then, Ryan and his girlfriend faced strange scratches and noises in a remote Scottish cottage, fleeing in fear. Finally, sensitive to spirits, Sophia encountered both gentle […]
The Bear Hugging Demon It is listener submission time again and we can a couple of wild stories for you! Over several years, Yasmin experienced a series of inexplicable encounters that began in 2011 when she and her family witnessed a triangular UFO near their grandmother’s house, followed by sensing an invisible presence in her […]
The Day of the Dead This week, we explore the Day of the Dead (DÃa de los Muertos), a Mexican holiday celebrated on November 1st and 2nd when the gates of heaven are believed to open, allowing children’s spirits to return on the first day and adults’ spirits on the second day. We discuss how […]