Bobby Mackey’s Music World | Ep. 40 This week we head on down to Kentucky and discuss Bobby Mackey’s Music World. Considered the most haunted night club in America, Bobby Mackey’s Music World has a dark past involving a slaughterhouse, Mafia transactions, death, exorcisms, and a bloody well that is considered a portal to Hell. […]
The Children with the Caul | Ep. 39 It’s Listener Submission time again! This episode takes place in Maryland and involves Priya and her two prophetic friends, Mick and Kelly. We talk about dreams, shadow figures looming over beds, ghost hunting, and terrifying demonic creatures in attics. You don’t want to miss this one! If […]
Haunted Disney | Ep. 37 What could possibly be scary about the most magical place on Earth? Besides your wallet, apparently a lot. In this episode, we tackle Haunted Disney. Creepy and disturbing tales, urban legends, deaths, and experiences that span both Disney World and Disney Land. From saying “hello” to George to a mysterious […]
The Scribner Hill Devil | Ep. 33 Wow! It’s been a long time since we’ve had a listener submission episode. We are glad to dive back into submitted paranormal stories and boy this is a great one. This episode has everything you could want – a cemetery, an urban legend, possession, and shadow figures. Centered […]
The Hauntings of Ohio University | Ep. 32 All hands on deck! We have finally gotten spooky again. Well, we think so. Get out your pencils, notebooks, and pocketbook! We’re heading to college. In this homegrown episode from our home state, we break down the ghost stories surrounding Ohio University. We haunted dorms, cuddling ghosts, […]
The Legend of Resurrection Mary | Ep. 27 Have you ever picked up a hitchhiker? What if the hitchhiker was a seemingly harmless young girl? It may not seem that creepy until you look over and she has disappeared! This week, we discuss the Chicago urban legend of Resurrection Mary. This story follows the tragic […]
Helltown, Ohio | Live | Ep. 26 We decided to upload our LIVE Halloween special from Helltown, Ohio. The original location we planned on filming was closed, so we had to go off the beaten bath and up a trail to find a space, but it worked! From ghost hearses and broken down school buses […]
Haunted Sets and Films: The Exorcist and Poltergeist | Ep. 23 This is the ultimate scary movie time as Halloween is quickly approaching, so why not take a deeper look at a few horror film classics? However, these movies aren’t just classic scary flicks, they are known for having cursed sets! From accidents, injuries, and […]
The Shadow Man | Listener Submission | Ep. 20 We are excited to present another listener submission bonus episode! This story comes to us from Jessica, who recounts 3 main experiences with a shadow man. From her childhood to her own son’s experience, it appears she has a ghost presence that has been keeping close […]
The Possession of Anneliese Michel | Ep. 19 For the first time on Believing the Bizarre. This episode covers the terrifying possession of Anneliese Michel. Fun fact, this is the possession case that the 2005 film The Exorcism of Emily Rose was loosely based on. Diving into this potential possession turns into a debate regarding […]