The Amityville Horror

The Amityville Horror A tragic family murder spree mixed with ghosts and terrifying hauntings. No wonder the Amityville Horror is such a popular topic! We discuss the DeFeo family murders, the Lutz family hauntings, and of course, the Warren’s appearance. While the Amityville Horror house is a huge topic in the paranormal and true crime […]

Read More

The Mansfield Reformatory

The Mansfield Reformatory | Ep. 129 It’s easy to understand why a large prison may be haunted. Now, throw in decades of abuse, violence, and suicide. That terrifying combination gives you the Mansfield Reformatory. This Ohio State Reformatory is known as being incredibly haunted, with guests often seeing shapes and shadows and being touched by […]

Read More

The Battersea Poltergeist | Ep. 124

The Battersea Poltergeist | Ep. 124 One of the UK’s scariest Poltergeist experiences involves a young girl, Shirley, that was tormented for 12 years. Beyond experiencing terrifying notes and levitating from her bed, her family’s house consistently rattled, objects flew across rooms, and fires randomly started throughout the home. But is it believable? Listen now. […]

Read More

The Haunted Den | Ep. 120

The Haunted Den | Ep. 120 Welcome to another episode of Believing the Bizarre! This week, we have two hauntingly good listener submissions, from Nora and Cyndi. One story involves a Civil War General-like shadow figure and the other is a collection of creepy and unsettling moments, including intense nightmares, lurking shadow figures, and terrifying […]

Read More

The Familial Spirits | Ep. 117

The Familial Spirits | Listener Submission | Ep. 117 This week, it is listener submission time again and we have a few hauntings for you from two separate listeners. In one case, we have a seemingly very haunted home with a skeptical narrator that isn’t quite sure if all of the home’s spooks are what […]

Read More

The Suffocating Shadow Man | Ep. 114

The Suffocating Shadow Man | Ep. 114 It’s listener submission time again and we have two stories this week. First, a terrifying and tribal ghost story from Veronica. Then, our main story, involves a protective and occasionally hostile shadow figure told to us by Sara. This shadow figure seems to have an uncanny ability to […]

Read More

The Malevolent Shadows | Ep. 111

The Malevolent Shadows | Ep. 111 This week, we have two submitted stories that we will be discussing. The first is sent to us by Megan, co-host of Hidden in the Shadows Podcast. She is very sensitive and has had plenty of paranormal encounters, but she submitted one of her very first encounters which potentially […]

Read More