The Scribner Hill Devil | Ep. 33 Wow! It’s been a long time since we’ve had a listener submission episode. We are glad to dive back into submitted paranormal stories and boy this is a great one. This episode has everything you could want – a cemetery, an urban legend, possession, and shadow figures. Centered […]
The Hauntings of Ohio University | Ep. 32 All hands on deck! We have finally gotten spooky again. Well, we think so. Get out your pencils, notebooks, and pocketbook! We’re heading to college. In this homegrown episode from our home state, we break down the ghost stories surrounding Ohio University. We haunted dorms, cuddling ghosts, […]
Are Humans Naturally From Earth? | Ep. 31 Welcome to another episode of Believing the Bizarre! Today, we tackle a crazy existential question – what if humans are not naturally from planet Earth? That’s absolutely crazy! We have to be from Earth, right? Well, when you start looking at some of the stark differences between […]
The Moon Landing Conspiracy | Ep. 30 This week on Believing the Bizarre, we tackle a major conspiracy! The moon landing! Did we ever actually go to the moon? Of course we did, right? Or did we let our nationality and pride get the best of us? Did we fake the event with the help […]
The Jersey Devil | Ep. 29 This week, we tackle the heavily requested and popular cryptic, the Jersey Devil. Hailing from Pine Barren, NJ, The Jersey Devil is said to have the head of a goat/horse, leathery wings, clawed hands, and hooved feet. We discuss this cryptid’s origin stories, along with some of the more […]
The Lost Colony of Roanoke | Ep. 28 While you have likely heard about the Lost Colony of Roanoke, you may not be updated on all of the theories surrounding this mysterious event. As a refresher, a group of 100+ people vanished without a trace on Roanoke Island in 1590. All that was left was […]
The Legend of Resurrection Mary | Ep. 27 Have you ever picked up a hitchhiker? What if the hitchhiker was a seemingly harmless young girl? It may not seem that creepy until you look over and she has disappeared! This week, we discuss the Chicago urban legend of Resurrection Mary. This story follows the tragic […]
Helltown, Ohio | Live | Ep. 26 We decided to upload our LIVE Halloween special from Helltown, Ohio. The original location we planned on filming was closed, so we had to go off the beaten bath and up a trail to find a space, but it worked! From ghost hearses and broken down school buses […]
The Multi-Universe Theory | Listener Submission | Ep. 25 Whoa! A listener submission episode that is about… multi-universes!? That is right! Welcome to Believing the Bizarre, where we dive into the unknown and unusual and tell you whether or not we find it believable. This week, we take a look at stories from Isaac and […]
In this episode of Believing the Bizarre, we discuss one of the original vampire stories in the United States of America, the Vampire Mercy Brown. […]