The Grafton Monster On a fateful night in June 1964, Robert Cockrell’s drive home through Grafton, West Virginia, took an unexpected turn when he encountered a massive, headless creature with smooth, rubbery skin. This bizarre sighting sparked a town-wide frenzy, with armed locals combing the woods in search of what became known as the Grafton […]
The Filicidal Ghost In this episode of Believing the Bizarre, we dive into more listener submission stories. From shared dreams of pink goo monsters to pendulum divinations revealing shocking truths about human identity, these stories blur the line between the ordinary and the extraordinary. We explore a chilling encounter at an abandoned mansion in Florida, […]
The Shadow at Grandma’s Funeral Another Tuesday and another Believing the Bizarre episode! We have 3 creepy listener submissions for you this week. The first story follows Adrianna, where she see discovers her little cousin hiding under a bed, only to find out that there was no way she could have been there… Our second […]
The Bloody Shadow Our first story takes us to Rexburg, Idaho, where Sydney experiences a series of unsettling events in her college apartment, including mysterious knocks, moving objects, and a terrifying shadow figure. The haunting escalates until a blessing brings peace, only for Sydney to face another frightening encounter on a mountain trip with friends. […]
The Possession of Clara Germana Cele In 1906, Clara, a 16-year-old orphan at St. Michaels Mission in Natal, South Africa, began exhibiting strange behaviors. Initially kind and devout, she started talking to unseen entities, claiming she had made a deal with Satan. Her behavior escalated to tearing at her clothes, growling, and speaking in languages […]
The Bermuda Triangle The Bermuda Triangle, also known as the Devil’s Triangle, is a vast 500,000 square mile area in the Atlantic Ocean bounded by Miami, Bermuda, and Puerto Rico. This region has been the site of numerous mysterious disappearances of ships and aircraft over the years, leading to its infamous reputation. The area is […]
Extraterrestrial Encounters: Vol 2 In this episode, we explore four intriguing UFO encounters from across the United States. James from Akron, Ohio recounts a childhood experience where he and two others witnessed strange red lights in the sky that split, moved, and vanished mysteriously. In Alaska, Julian shares his father’s story of encountering an intense […]
The Faceless Woman In this episode of Believing the Bizarre, hosts Charlie and Tyler dive into three chilling listener-submitted stories of paranormal encounters. The first tale recounts eerie events following a tragic death, including possible possession, that leave the hosts questioning if it’s truly the spirit of the deceased or something more sinister. Next, they […]
Mysterious Disappearances: Vol. 1 It’s time for 3 intriguing and mysterious disappearance stories! Our first story involves Frederick Valentich. Fred was a young Australian pilot who vanished during a routine flight in 1978. Despite his struggles with exams, Fred pursued his dream of flying, only to disappear under bizarre circumstances. Moments before his disappearance, Fred […]
Cursed Games: Part 4 It’s time for another installment of Cursed Games and we have 3 creepy games for you this episode!Dive into the chilling world of supernatural games with “The Red Book,” a Mexican divination ritual.Using a hard-cover red book and candlelight, players seek permission to enter and exit the game, asking questions and […]