The Watcher of 657 Boulevard | Ep. 22 Welcome to another episode of Believing the Bizarre. In this episode, we get into the creepy and stalker-ish story of The Watcher of 657 Boulevard in Westfield, New Jersey. Derek and Maria Broaddus bought a beautiful dream house only to begin receiving anonymous letters from The Watcher […]
The Flatwoods Monster | Ep. 21 We return to West Virginia for this legend, but instead of Mothman, we are discussing the Flatwoods Monster. In September of 1952, a group of boys playing football witnessed a pulsing red light fly across the sky and land on a nearby hill. They ran home to tell their […]
The Shadow Man | Listener Submission | Ep. 20 We are excited to present another listener submission bonus episode! This story comes to us from Jessica, who recounts 3 main experiences with a shadow man. From her childhood to her own son’s experience, it appears she has a ghost presence that has been keeping close […]
The Possession of Anneliese Michel | Ep. 19 For the first time on Believing the Bizarre. This episode covers the terrifying possession of Anneliese Michel. Fun fact, this is the possession case that the 2005 film The Exorcism of Emily Rose was loosely based on. Diving into this potential possession turns into a debate regarding […]
The Fresno Nightcrawler | Ep. 18 This week, we dive back into the world of cryptids. Popular in Fresno, California and Yosemite National Park, we breakdown The Fresno Nightcrawler. Are these white and long-legged creatures natural cryptids from Earth or are they alien beings from a distant swamp-like planet? Find out as we discuss the […]
The 9/11 Conspiracies | Ep. 17 This is a touchy and relevant subject, but it is also highly discussed when it comes to conspiracy theories. This episode, we tactfully discuss 3 common conspiracy theories that surround the 9/11 tragedy and tell you which ones we buy and which ones are ridiculous. Of course, it needn’t […]
The Haunting in Houston | Listener Submission | Ep. 16 This week, a new listener submission episode comes to us all the way from Houston, Texas. This episode follows Nathaniel and some of the creepy experiences he has witnessed in his own home, from people appearing in Skype chats behind him to cries heard from […]
The Abduction of Antonio Villas Boas | Ep. 15 It’s time to circle back to aliens! This week, we tackle one of the original abduction stories, even before Betty and Barney Hill. The story of Antonio Villas Boas, a farmer in Brazil in the 1950s, is filled with incredible detail and unexpected twists and turns. […]
The Legend of Mothman | Ep. 14 In 1966, the West Virginia town of Point Pleasant had multiple witnesses and encounters with this creature that had wings and red eyes. This was the beginning of Mothman, which became a local urban legend. Its appearances ultimately foreshadowed the collapse of the Silver Bridge in the Ohio […]
The Cursed Cabin | Listener Submission | Ep. 13 It’s Friday and you’re listening to another Believing the Bizarre episode. This can only mean one thing… another listener submission episode! Coming to us all the way from Chile, this story, by listener Pask, involves playing with a ouija board and cursing a family cabin. Creepy […]