Helltown, Ohio | Live | Ep. 26 We decided to upload our LIVE Halloween special from Helltown, Ohio. The original location we planned on filming was closed, so we had to go off the beaten bath and up a trail to find a space, but it worked! From ghost hearses and broken down school buses […]
Haunted Sets and Films: The Exorcist and Poltergeist | Ep. 23 This is the ultimate scary movie time as Halloween is quickly approaching, so why not take a deeper look at a few horror film classics? However, these movies aren’t just classic scary flicks, they are known for having cursed sets! From accidents, injuries, and […]
The Shadow Man | Listener Submission | Ep. 20 We are excited to present another listener submission bonus episode! This story comes to us from Jessica, who recounts 3 main experiences with a shadow man. From her childhood to her own son’s experience, it appears she has a ghost presence that has been keeping close […]
The Possession of Anneliese Michel | Ep. 19 For the first time on Believing the Bizarre. This episode covers the terrifying possession of Anneliese Michel. Fun fact, this is the possession case that the 2005 film The Exorcism of Emily Rose was loosely based on. Diving into this potential possession turns into a debate regarding […]
The Haunting in Houston | Listener Submission | Ep. 16 This week, a new listener submission episode comes to us all the way from Houston, Texas. This episode follows Nathaniel and some of the creepy experiences he has witnessed in his own home, from people appearing in Skype chats behind him to cries heard from […]
The Cursed Cabin | Listener Submission | Ep. 13 It’s Friday and you’re listening to another Believing the Bizarre episode. This can only mean one thing… another listener submission episode! Coming to us all the way from Chile, this story, by listener Pask, involves playing with a ouija board and cursing a family cabin. Creepy […]
La Pascualita and The Expressionless | Ep. 12 A little unique opening to this Believing the Bizarre episode! Tyler wanted to make the creepypasta, The Expressionless, into an episode but wasn’t able to find an angle to make it work. Because, you know, it’s fake. So we read that story in full before diving into […]
Paper Magic and the Girl | Listener Submission | EP. 9 Surprise! It’s another bonus episode thanks to fantastic listeners submitting their creepy stories! Today, we have a double-header. Our first story comes from Pennsylvania and involves abandoned buildings, satanic markings, and possible attachments. Our second tale takes place in Florida and involves an eerie […]
The Nameless Horror of 50 Berkeley Square | Ep. 8 *Disclaimer: due to a COVID-19 scare, this episode was recorded social distantly. The audio is a little subpar compared to what you’re used to, but the good news is, we are both fine.* But, you probably care more about the audio than our health. That’s […]